Monday 21 January 2008

nt.number theory - Irrational logs and the harmonic series

Consider the series
$$ S_f = sum_{x=1}^infty frac{f}{x^2+fx}. $$
Goldbach showed that, for integers $f ge 1$,
$$ S_f = 1 + frac12 + frac13 + ldots + frac1f $$
(this follows easily by writing $S_f$ as a telescoping series).
Thus $S_f$ is rational for all natural numbers $f ge 1$.
Goldbach claimed that, for all nonintegral (rational) numbers $f$,
the sum $S_f$ would be irrational.



Euler showed, by using the substitution
$$ frac1k = int_0^1 x^{k-1} dx, $$
that
$$ S_f = int_0^1 frac{1-x^f}{1-x} dx. $$
He evaluated this integral for $f = frac12$ and found
that $S_{1/2} = 2(1 - ln 2)$ (this also follows easily from
Goldbach's series for $S_f$). Thus Goldbach's claim holds for all
$f equiv frac12 bmod 1$ since $S_{f+1} = S_f + frac1{f+1}$.



Here are my questions:



  1. The irrationality of $ln 2$ was established by Lambert, who
    proved that $e^r$ is irrational for all rational numbers
    $r ne 0$. Are there any (simple) direct proofs?


  2. Has Goldbach's claim about the irrationality of $S_f$ for
    nonintegral rational values of $f$ been settled in other cases?


No comments:

Post a Comment