Monday 17 August 2015

lord of the rings - Why did Thorongil warn Ecthelion against the White Wizard?

Not sure where this is in the annals, but it says in the Tolkien Companion by J.E.A. Tyler that:




Saruman made his first deliberate move in this direction (toward imposing his will, which was forbidden of the Istari) in the year 2759 Third Age, when he appeared at the Coronation of King Frealaf of Rohan, successor of the mighty Helm Hammerhand. The Wizard brough with him rich presents, and declared himself the friend of Rohan and gondor, and a little later was able to persuade Steward Beren of Gondor to grant him the Keys of Orthanc, the mighty Tower which, together with its fortress of Isengard, commanded the strategic Gap of Rohan. All thought this was a welcome move.




All, that is, except a weary ranger who would see everything given up by Gondor as a challenge to its power.



And it further says that




all the time the Wizard was secretly searching the Tower of Orthanc for a long-lost treasure of the Dunedain ... the Palantir of Orthanc.




Then in 2851 the White Council met to think of ways to stop Sauron from coming back




Saruman, hoping that the Ring would expose its location if Sauron were left unharassed, deliberately overruled a strong recommendation (from Gandalf) ... that Dol Guldur be attacked.




By his actions, Gandalf may have suspected that Saruman was up to something, although I don't think Gandalf even knew of the Ring.



So, either through his own understanding of the Palantir through the lore of his people or through his association with Gandalf, Aragorn was more naturally suspicious than Gandalf and I think it makes sense that he'd know something was amiss well before anyone else had reason to suspect.

No comments:

Post a Comment